CEOs for Cities is a national network of urban leaders dedicated to building and sustaining the next generation of great American cities.

As I travel U.S. cities, it is unusual for public transit not to come up as a priority.  But buses are rarely mentioned.  Cities want the sexy stuff -- light rail, trolleys and trams.  I was reminded of this as I was reading again about Bogota's Bus Rapid Transit (BRT) and London's newly redesigned buses. 

Bogota's TransMilenio, which features fully enclosed stations positioned between four lanes of buses (two on either side going in opposite directions) situated inside four outside lanes four cars, is the star system.  Buses and stations are made for group passenger loading, eliminating the most irritating source of slow travel.  And the TransMilenio carries none of the negative stereotypes associated with buses.  Former Mayor Enrique Penalosa attributes that to "clever rebranding."  As he told The New York Times, "People don't say, 'I'm taking the bus.'  They say, 'I'm taking TransMilenio.'"

According to the NYT, subways cost more than 30 times as much per mile to build than BRT and three times as much to maintain.  Plus, they are very quick to build.

Can't US cities figure out how to deploy BRT to their advantage.


Bookmark and Share   

discussion(2)

Randy Simes, July 19, 2009

There are political issues in the U.S. that make BRT undesirable. Many places that have installed things like BRT who HOV lanes along interstates have later gone in and repainted the lines to allow regular traffic to once again use that road space. There is no real fixed space for BRT and is often used as a political ploy by transit opponents as something they would be for, which they later intend to be against, or remove. I agree that our bus systems need to be improved and GPS real-time arrival, traffic light timing/priority and more bonafide stations would help tremendously. Unfortunately we can't seem to muster the political support to fund even our current systems, much less anything like this. And it's not as if it's an either or thing, as the cities that have light rail, streetcars and trams often have excellent bus service as well. Seattle is a great example of this as they have articulated buses, dedicated stations and nicely designed buses to go along with their modern streetcars, light rail and even monorail.

Link: http://www.UrbanCincy.com/

Steven, July 20, 2009

It's not that they've eliminated the "negative stereotype" of taking the bus. If you read the article, you'll find the reason TransMillenio is successful is because: "Bogotá removed one-third of its street parking to make room for TransMilenio and imposed alternate-day driving restrictions determined by license plate numbers, forcing car owners onto the system." So, on alternate days, people don't have much of a choice other than to take TransMilenio. I'd love to see the reaction to THAT if it was tried in any American city.

Post a Comment



captcha img

Please leave the following field blank:

*Required fields (your email address will not be published)